The Left Berlin News & Comment

This is the archive template

Transparency – release the Minutes of the Cancellation of the Breitz Exhibition

Open Letter in support of Candice Breitz


03/05/2024

Translated from the German. Original version here

Dear Minister Streichert-Clivot,


On March 18, 2024, a detailed statement by Candice Breitz regarding the cancellation of her exhibition at the Saarlandmuseum was published in the Saarbrücker Zeitung. Unfortunately, you have not yet commented or responded. Rumors continue to circulate in the art and culture scene. In the absence of any public discussion, people are talking behind closed doors…

We–authors, filmmaker, artists and journalists–are writing to express our concern regarding recent developments in connection with the cancellation of the exhibition. Across the press, concerns about artistic freedom and fundamental democratic values have been raised. Candice Breitz accuses you not only of putting pressure on the director of the Saarlandmuseum, Andrea Jahn (including forbidding her to give public interviews), but also of having excluded Jahn from the decision-making process regarding the cancellation of the exhibition.

These accusations, if true, are likely to undermine confidence in your leadership as Minister for Education and Culture. You yourself emphasize the need for transparency and clarification in the democratic process. We therefore suggest that, in order to facilitate this transparency, you make the relevant minutes of the meeting in which the decision to cancel Candice Breitz’s exhibition available for inspection. We believe that disclosure is necessary in order to thoroughly review the process and thus strengthen confidence in Saarland’s cultural policy and the integrity of its cultural decision-making processes.

We appeal to your responsibility as Minister of Culture to do justice to the cultural and democratic values that hold our society together. The promotion of art and culture, the preservation of freedom of expression and the transparent debate with critical voices are essential for a vibrant and open society.

With hope for a constructive debate as we anticipate your reply,

Klaus Behringer
Prof. Sung-Hyung Cho
Andreas Dury
Prof. Dr. Meinrad Maria Grewenig
Prof. Ulrike Rosenbach
Daniel Hausig
Sigrún Ólafsdóttir
Dr. Ralph Schock
Prof. Georg Winter

 

To sign or share the petition follow this  link or the QR code below

Letter from the Editors: 2nd May 2024

Relaunching theleftberlin


02/05/2024


On Thursday at the K19 Café (Kreutziger Straße 19), Udi Raz from the Jüdische Stimme is talking on Green Politics and Racial Supremacy in Palestine. Udi offers a historical contextualization of the perception of the relationship between the categories of “the land” and “the people” in Zionist knowledge production, and shows, through contemporary examples, how Green Politics are being deployed by Zionists in order to maintain Jewish Supremacy between the Jordan River and the Mediterranean Sea, through practices of genocide and epistemicide. The meeting starts at 8pm, and will be preceded by a vegan Küfa from 6.30pm.

Friday sees the opening of an exhibition Palestinian Identities in Ulme35 (Ulmenallee 35). Ulme35 and the der Ibn Rushd Fund invite you to spend an evening exploring Palestinian identities. Different artistic positions open perspectives of what these could be. Students and Almuni of Bard College Berlin will show short films and sketches. The evening also sees the opening of the exhibition Eyes of Gaza, a collection of photos young people in Gaza took of their world in 2020. When Eyes of Gaza was last shown in Berlin, we reviewed it in theleftberlin. The exhibition will run until the middle of June.

On Saturday, there’s a demonstration Solidarity with Palestine. Stop the genocide in Gaza! Stop the project of Israeli settler colonialism! Stop the renewed forced displacement of Palestinians! Stop Nakba 2.0! The demonstration starts at 3pm at the corner of Wilmersdorferstraße and Kantstraße.

On Sunday, it’s our latest Palestine Reading Group, where we’ll be discussing Socialist perspectives on Palestinian liberation. You can find the selected reading here. The Palestine Reading Group takes place every week, on either Friday or Sunday. Check the page of Events we organise for the coming dates and discussion topics. If you’d like to get more involved in the group, you can join our Telegram group and follow the channel Reading group. The Reading Group starts at 7pm, and there is a meeting for Moderators at 6.30pm open to everyone who’s interested.

On Monday, at 7pm, there is a Meeting to found a new theleftberlin Group. theleftberlin was initially a journalistic project, responsible for our Website and, later, this Newsletter. Organising meetings and other Events was mainly in the hands of the Berlin LINKE Internationals. At its most recent organising meeting, the Berlin LINKE Internationals decided to restrict their work to Events done in direct contact with die LINKE, and to let theleftberlin organise everything else. If you like what we do, and are interested in getting more involved, or are just curious about our work, please come along. It’s in Ferat Kocak’s office, Schierker Straße 26.

Also on Monday evening, Emily Dische-Becker & Basma al-Sharif will be leading a talk on censorship in Berlin, accompanied by the German premiere of Basma al-Sharif’s short film Capital. Emily Dische-Becker is a writer, organizer, and curator. She’s the German director of Diaspora Alliance. Basma al-Sharif is a Palestinian artist working in cinema and installation. The evening is part of Making Waves – a series of monthly screenings, talks, and lectures, on freedom of speech, art as resistance, Palestine, the German question, and more. Making Waves is organized by Khomasi, who are our Campaign of the Week.

One for your diary. Next Saturday, 11th May, theleftberlin is organising Palivision – an evening of live performance for everyone who wants to observe the boycott of Eurovision 2024. Besides 11 musical acts, there will be speeches by Palestinian lawyer Nadija Samour, Udi Raz from the Jüdische Stimme, plus representatives of the Palestine Campaign, Handala Leipzig, GewerkschafterInnen4Gaza, and KlimafürPalästina. All money raised at PALIVISION will be donated to the European Legal Support Centre to help their fight against the repression of Palestine Solidarity in Germany. The event takes place in AlHamra (Raumer Straße 16). Doors open at 6pm, but be early as places are limited. The first act is on at 7pm. More information in next week’s Newsletter.

There is much more going on in Berlin this week. To find out what’s happening, go to our Events page. You can also see a shorter, but more detailed list of events in which we are directly involved here.

If you are looking for Resources on Palestine, we have set up a page with useful links. We will be continually updating the page, so if you would like to recommend other links, please contact us on team@theleftberlin.com. You can also find all the reading from our Palestine Reading Groups here. You can also visit the Palestine film evening every Wednesday at 8.30pm in Al Hamra. The title of the film is usually released too late for us to name it in this Newsletter, but you can stay informed by following Al Hamra on Instagram and facebook.

In News from Berlin, Berlin police ban speaking Gaelic at the Camp for Gaza, transport senator resigns after alleged plagiarism, and Ferat Koçak attacks the deportation of and adult and a child with mental illness.

In News from Germany, Germany will probably support EU environmental reforms, first trial of the Reichsbürger begins, and following a demonstration in Hamburg against Islamophobia the interior minister calls for “tough intervention”, lastly inflation in Germany starts to level out.

Read all about it in this week’s News from Berlin and Germany.

New on theleftberlin, Dan Weissmann examines the popular German columnist repeating Israeli army propaganda, Helga Baumgarten, professor at the Bir Zeit University looks at the writings of  Constantine Zurayk and Salman Abu Sitta, Isobel Knight looks at the worrying recent case which highlights femicide in Kazakhstan, Ilya Kharkow worries about a murder in Kyiv, Roser Garí Pére condemns Germany’s proud complicity in genocide in Gaza, Alan Fernandes examines the trial following the murder of Brazilian socialist Marielle Franco, and we publish die Linke’s short manifesto for the coming European elections.

This week’s Video of the Week shows the production of the latest merchandise available from theleftberlin. Palestine T-shirts cost €15, or 3 for €40. Tote bags are €10. We also have a limited number of posters and other merch. Merchandise is available at all theleftberlin events, including Palestine reading groups and Palivision (although we sold all of the current batch of tote bags on 1st May). You can contact us beforehand at team@theleftberlin.com to ensure that we will have what you’re after. Profits made from the merch will be shared between improving theleftberlin website and the European Legal Support Centre for its work defending Palestinians and their supporters in Germany.

You can follow us on the following social media:

If you would like to contribute any articles or have any questions or criticisms about our work, please contact us at team@theleftberlin.com. And please do encourage your friends to subscribe to this Newsletter.

Keep on fighting,

The Left Berlin Editorial Board

10 Reasons to vote Die Linke

European Election Programme of Die Linke (short version)


01/05/2024

The European elections will be held on June 9th. Die Linke is campaigning for a socially just European Union and for the fair redistribution of wealth in Europe. We are fighting for climate justice and climate protection and for peace. The government and the Right are calling for more armament, stronger militaries, and higher walls around Europe. The concerns of the people are seldom represented; the ‘everyday’ is no longer possible. Those who have enough concerns of their own are burdened with the costs of transitioning to green energy. Our vision for Europe looks different: we stand for greater collective welbeing, more fairness, more equality; for hospitals and care facilities not traded on the European stock exchange; for functioning public transport at no cost to its passengers; for a railway that connects Europe. And that all may profit from Europe’s vast wealth. This is possible. Together we are strong—stronger than the Right, who use the poor and refugees as their scapegoats. Stronger than the lobbies that put corporate interests and armament first. That is why we ask for your vote.

1. Protect the climate—not corporate profits

Climate disaster threatens the survival of our children on our planet. The wealthier someone is, the more CO2 emissions they produce. 100 corporations are responsible for an inordinate share of all CO2 emissions. The federal government has failed to get a handle on these largest instigators of climate change. Companies receive state funding for making the switch to climate-friendly production. All the same, the subsequent profits and dividends land in private wallets.

CO2 prices—petty change for the mega rich—most affect those who already struggle to make ends meet.

Die Linke demands clear specifications and rules for companies and real alternatives for the people. We are fighting for a green transition with public energy producers and socially scaled pricing—for climate friendly economic restructuring that generates secure employment with good wages. To redistribute the burden of CO2 costs, we demand socioeconomically minded climate funds that will especially support those with low and middle incomes.

2. Living wages—not survival wages

Corporate profits are through the roof. Wages are not. Rent, groceries, gas, electricity, and heating costs are exploding. Many can no longer stretch their pay to the end of the month. More than 100 million people in Europe work for low pay as adjusted for the wages of their country. This is the case for one in six full-time employees in Germany—in the former East, that number is as high as one in three.

Companies exploit the low wages of other EU states for profit. The EU is against poverty wages and stipulates that as many workers as possible be protected by collective labour agreements. In Germany, less than half of workers enjoy such protections. Still, the German government does nothing. In Germany the federal minimum wage must be raised to 14.14 euros. Die Linke says: round up to 15!

Workplace pressure builds, a mountain of unpaid overtime grows. Die Linke is fighting for work that fits life in the form of a 4-day or 30 hour week with full pay and more employees.

3. Finding safety

It is not refugees who threaten our welfare, but the mega rich who hide their wealth in tax havens. We want an end to the fatality on EU borders and that no one is left to drown. International maritime law enshrines an obligation to at-sea rescue; something we wish to organise publicly, reliably and legally. Chaos on the borders is a political failure. Asylum procedures compatible with international law and human rights are essential. The costs must be equitably distributed within the EU. Municipalities that take in refugees must be granted additional funds.

4. Abolishing poverty

More than 120 million people are in danger of poverty—including one in four children in Europe. Poverty does not look the same everywhere. Retirees collect bottles, families cannot afford vacations. Children go to school without breakfast. Others live on the streets. Many affected by poverty provide wealthier nations with cheap labour, for example as agricultural workers or 24-hour-care nurses.

Poverty is always a failure of the government. The EU must see that a social security net is provided to all member states—welfare and federal minimum wages must reliably protect from poverty. We demand that in Germany that no pension or welfare payments fall below 1,200 euros per month. Social security is prerequisite to a life in dignity. If corporations and the wealthy are held accountable, this is affordable. We stand for good social security benefits and against the need for them to be collected—because wages and pensions are sufficient for a good life, because public services are free, and because shelter and power are affordable.

5. No profits at the cost of health

Long waits for a doctor’s appointment, cancer surgery, in the emergency room; nursing staff are overworked and leave the branch exhausted—these are everyday phenomenon in Germany. The poor are more likely to suffer from chronic illness and to die earlier. This is true in Germany and across Europe.

Die Linke is fighting for better care for all, regardless of income. Other European countries invest more in healthcare, have more nursing staff per patient, and pay them better. This benefits the employed and their patients.

Die Linke aims to orient nursing and healthcare around communal wellbeing and according to need—rather than European competition rules. Hospitals and care homes should not be allowed to pass profits on to investors. Supplementary funds must be directed back into healthcare and nursing. The EU should set aside funds and assist municipalities in turning private hospitals over to public control.

6. Strengthening that which holds humanity and society together

Classrooms are too full. If a teacher is sick, lessons are cancelled. A free spot in a daycare is difficult to come by. Childcare workers are at their limits. The old apartment has long been too small for the family—there is no affordable, suitable housing. Functioning public transport and railways, or a public library and youth centre? In many areas, the suggestion sounds utopian. Good public services are the glue that holds humankind and society together, or not. Those who can afford to send their children to private schools and purchase homes, do. The EU is pushing for privatisation and public services are at the behest of the market. This leaves traces everywhere in the EU and in our daily lives—private equals costly. Die Linke wants to remove priority for privatisation and profit orientation from EU accords. We are fighting for good public services with enough staff; for enough affordable housing. For education and childcare free of charge. For healthcare organised publicly and not for profit.

7. Wealth to benefit all

Half of Europe’s wealth is in the possession of its richest 1%. The COVID-19 pandemic, war, and crisis have meant less money and more worries for many. The wealth of the richest has grown significantly. Why? Because many countries—such as Germany—lowered taxes for the wealthy; because the prices of rent, power, and groceries have been driven up, and the government is funnelling huge sums of money into armament. This makes corporate owners and shareholders rich. Class sizes could shrink, public transport could be cheaper, and there could be more daycare spaces if a wealth tax was reintroduced in Germany.

Inequality between the top and bottom is growing, as does the inequality between EU member states. This is bad for the people, for cohesion in the EU, and for democracy. We want to raise taxes on corporate profits and the wealth and inheritances of the mega rich throughout the EU. We demand a wealth tax starting at assets of 1 million euros (debts subtracted) in Germany. Assets over 1 billion euros will be taxed at 12%; no one needs more than 999 million euros.

8. Free public transport—not private jets

Well connected public transport, free and for all: beneficial to us, our cities and the environment. We want to expand public transport throughout the EU and make it available free of charge. More transit lines, accessibility, higher frequency service, better connection for rural areas and improved working conditions will require investment in the billions; then, public transport will pose a real alternative to car travel and all would be mobile. Through a well-functioning railway system, we can bring Europe closer together and expand daily commuter routes.

With better track networks, modern coaches, and comfortable night trains, Die Linke wants to make rail the most important form of transportation in Europe—for an affordable price. This way, train travel will be a real alternative to flying. Socially just climate protection means stopping the excesses of the mega rich. We want superyachts and private jets banned in the EU and to abolish tax breaks for aviation fuel.

9. Cap profits, close tax havens

Shell, Lidl, Aldi, and other corporations raised prices during the war and energy crisis. Necessities have increased in cost by one third; energy costs by one half. Excessive pricing has been cushioned with tax money. Taxpayers were left in the cold all the same. Inflation is no force of nature. Price increases tell us that we must pay more while corporate profits increase. Die Linke wants to prevent profiteering from crises. This is possible—if excessive profits are taxed away, raising prices loses its attractiveness. We demand a 90% excess profit tax in the EU on all surplus profits. Electricity and gas prices cannot be left to the market. We want socially-scaled pricing. International corporate giants pay an average of just 19% taxes, while the neighbourhood baker pays around 30%. We want to put a stop to tax havens and tax evasion, through which 835 billion euros escape the EU every year. We want standardised minimum tax rates for Europe’s large companies.

10. Investment in peace—not war

Putin’s criminal war of aggression in the Ukraine has shocked many. The EU has obligated member states to invest more money in armament. The German government quickly set aside 100 billion euros for the Bundeswehr. The result for some: extra arms-industry profits, with stock values increasing tenfold. For the rest of us: pension cuts, child poverty, care sector and housing crises. As the armament budget goes up, basic child welfare has been abolished. Now, discussions of implementing ground forces and the use of atomic weapons are being held. Escalation and dying carry on. Reliance on escalation brings with it the risk of a world war.

Die Linke wants to outlaw war as a political tool. Negotiations for ceasefire and peace are needed over more arms shipments. We want to ban atomic weapons. If economic lobby representatives propose that we must choose between ‘guns and butter’, then we say, ‘Butter for all!’ Stop the arms race!

Translation: Shav MacKay, reproduced with permission

News from Berlin and Germany, 1st May 2024

Weekly news round-up from Berlin and Germany

NEWS FROM BERLIN

Berlin police say protests can only be held in German or English

After a pro-Palestine camp protest held by the group “Irish Bloc” outside the German parliament, police in Berlin have said certain protests in the capital city can only be conducted in German, English and, in some cases, Arabic, unless a police-assigned interpreter is present. Despite Irish being one of the EU’s 22 official languages, Berlin police have confirmed that the Gaelic language is forbidden at the protest camp. The Irish Bloc is among several pro-Palestine groups in Berlin which have been targeted recently. In late March, the “Jüdische Stimme für gerechten Frieden in Nahost” (“Jewish Voice for a Just Peace in the Middle East”) received notice from a Berlin state run bank its account had been frozen. Source: iamexpat

Berlin transport senator Manja Schreiner resigns after PhD scandel

Berlin’s transport senator Manja Schreiner (CDU) is resigning. In a brief statement, the politician said the University of Rostock would revoke her doctorate. To prevent damage to the Berlin Senate, she had therefore asked the Governing Mayor Kai Wegner (CDU) for her dismissal. Schreiner emphasised she had not deliberately deceived or cheated at any point in her dissertation. As a private individual, she would therefore appeal against the decision. The Berlin mayor Kai Wegner (CDU) announced he would honour Schreiner’s request. It has not yet been decided who will take her place. Source: rbb

Deportation despite endangered child welfare

MP Ferat Koçak (the Left), a refugee policy expert, has criticised the deportation of a parent and a child with mental illness. Koçak affirms: “The child was just stable enough to attend school again. The deportation threatens to massively worsen the health situation of the child and parent again.” According to a statement from several aid organisations, both family members were “lured” to an appointment at the Berlin Immigration Office (LEA) and then deported to Moldova. Berlin’s interior senator Iris Spranger (SPD) told the interior committee that deportations are carried out only if all other legal means have been exhausted. Source: nd-aktuell

 

NEWS FROM GERMANY

Germany will probably not say no

According to Agriculture Minister Cem Özdemir (Greens), Germany will probably not vote against the abolition of important environmental rules for agricultural subsidies in the Council of EU member states. The last two years have “not always been harmonious” in the coalition government, “so I could imagine that we have different ideas on this issue”, said the politician to “taz”. The recent reform of EU agricultural subsidies on “compulsory fallow land” was, for nature conservationists, one of the few advances, which amount to around 55 billion euros per year. Source: taz

Reichsbürger trial: coup plan and rudimentary theories

They allegedly wanted nothing less than a coup d’état: the group of so-called “Reich Citizens” around Henry XIII Prince Reuss probably wanted to infiltrate the German Bundestag and arrest members of parliament. Particularly targeted were the Federal Chancellor Olaf Scholz (SPD), the Federal Foreign Minister Annalena Baerbock (Greens) and the CDU leader Friedrich Merz. However, a nationwide raid on the suspected right-wing terrorist organisation “Patriotic Union” on 7 December 2022 was successful: 25 people were arrested, including Reuß. This week in Stuttgart begins the first of three trials against the group. Judgements in all trials are not expected until next year. Source: dw

Islamists call for caliphate at Hamburg demo

Over 1,000 people have protested in Hamburg against what they see as Islamophobic politics and media. The rally was secured by a large contingent of police. There were no incidents. Slogans such as “Caliphate is the solution” could be read on posters. The “Muslim Interactive” initiative disguises itself as a campaign to educate people about racism, however, it is one of the Islamist groups that are causing rifts to grow in the country. Following the demonstration, Federal Minister of the Interior Nancy Faeser (SPD) called for “tough intervention” by the state at such events and praised the work of the Hamburg police. Source: zdf

Inflation rate stabilises

The inflation rate in Germany has been falling since December. In April at least, the trend has not reversed. According to initial figures from the Federal Statistical Office, inflation remained at 2.2 per cent. Things are returning to normal after the sometimes-drastic price rises of the past two years. It is relevant to note that, core inflation, which is considered by economists a more reliable measure because it excludes food and energy prices, had fluctuated a little more. In March, core inflation was 3.3 per cent, in April it is now likely to have been 3.0 per cent. Source: taz

Khomasi

Open Discussion on Palestine

Making Waves is a series of events intended to cultivate open discussions on Palestine, freedom of speech, art as resistance, and the current socio-political climate in Germany.

In the series kick-off, Emily Dische-Becker & Basma al-Sharif will lead a talk on censorship in Berlin, accompanied by the German premiere of Basma al-Sharif’s short film Capital. The event takes place on May 6, 2024 at KM28 (Karl-Marx-Straße 28, 12043 Berlin) and starts at 20:30 (doors open at 20:00). Entry is by donation, with proceeds used to support invited artists/speakers and the rest being donated to UNRWA.

The talk will be held in English. The short film is in different languages and has English subtitles. KM28’s door has two steps to street level, and staff is available to assist those who need help entering the room.

Making Waves is curated by Khomasi (five in Arabic) a collective of five people committed to sparking change and fostering open dialogue in a time where censorship in Germany, and especially in Berlin, is becoming the norm.

More and updated information at Making Waves Berlin. You can contact Khomasi at khomasi.group@gmail.com

*Emily Dische-Becker is a writer, organizer, and curator. She’s the German director of Diaspora Alliance, an international organization dedicated to fighting antisemitism and its instrumentalization, as well as a researcher for Forensic Architecture. 

Basma al-Sharif is a Palestinian artist working in cinema and installation. Her practice looks at cyclical political conflicts and confronts the legacy of colonialism through satirical, immersive, and lyrical works.