The Left Berlin News & Comment

This is the archive template

News from Berlin and Germany, 29th May 2024

Weekly news round-up from Berlin and Germany


29/05/2024

NEWS FROM BERLIN

Police officer beats journalist during evacuation at the Humboldt University

A video documented how a police officer hits a reporter from the ‘Berliner Zeitung’ (BZ) during the evacuation of an occupied institute at Humboldt University (HU) on Thursday. As BZ reported on the next day, the reporter, who had identified himself as a representative of the press, was beaten by an officer while filming the eviction. The newspaper also published the video about the incident. The police commented on the article, saying the following: ‘We were not previously aware of this video.’ The authorities had sent it ‘immediately’ to the State Office of Criminal Investigation for evaluation. The Journalists’ association demands a “complete clarification”. Source: tagesspiegel

Rent demo on 1 June

The official website of the Left party invites citizens to a demonstration against the rise of rent prices. It considers that “While rents are being increased, many people receive horrendous utility bills and everything is more expensive, little is happening when it comes to wages. And while the federal government prevents improved tenant protection, the CDU-SPD Senate allows rents to rise at the state-owned housing companies and it delays the referendum.” They then invite people to join for a demonstration shortly before the European elections taking place at 2pm on June 1st at Potsdamer Platz. Source: die Linke

Separation of powers in danger

The Berliner Senate admits that the ‘Palestine Congress’ was hastily ended in April. State Secretary of the Interior Christian Hochgrebe (SPD) now admits that the four bans on political activity were imposed at very short notice and communicated to the police. Salman Abu Sitta himself was not informed of the ban either verbally or in writing. The organisers only found out about it while Sitta’s video greeting was already running, even though he had been announced as a speaker for weeks. Furthermore, during the eviction at Humboldt University, a lawyer was arrested and a journalist was beaten by police officers. Lawyer Michael Plöse doubts that the Senate acted lawfully. Source: taz

Berlin 29-euro ticket: 75,000 subscriptions sold in its first month

Almost one month after Berlin’s 29-euro public transport ticket first went on sale, 75,000 passengers subscribed for it. According to the Berlin Senate for Transportation, 85 percent of the 29-euro tickets were sold to existing customers who were transferring over from another kind of ticket. Transport authorities in other German federal states fear the Berlin-wide ticket could diminish the popularity of the Deutschlandticket. Criticism has also come from police and emergency services in Berlin, which, according to police union representative Stephan Weh, have had 31,8 million euros of funding cut at the expense of “internal security” services, namely ambulances and police cars, to fund the 29-euro ticket. Source: iamexpat

The statue of “comfort women”: is Berlin planning to remove it?

The Friedenstatue (the statue of peace) which was inaugurated in September of 2020, is a memorial for the so-called “comfort women”, the hundreds of thousands of women forced into sexual slavery by Japanese troops during the Second World War – as well as to stand as a symbol against sexual violence more widely. Meanwhile, the recent years have seen the Japanese government putting pressure on foreign cities to remove such memorials. During a diplomatic visit to Japan, mayor Kai Wegner (CDU) affirmed he is committed to ensuring there is a monument against violence against women, but a “one-sided representation should no longer take place.” Source: the berliner

Berlin State Secretary Claudia Elif Stutz resigns

Berlin’s new transport senator Ute Bonde (CDU) has lost an important member of staff. State Secretary Claudia Elif Stutz (CDU) has announced that she is leaving the transport administration. According to the ‘rbb’ and ‘B.Z.’, the dispute over the 29-euro ticket is one reason for the resignation. The previoud State Secretary had argued in favour of the reintroduction of the ticket in the Berlin-Brandenburg Transport Association (VBB). Bonde, the new transport senator as of last week and now Elif Stutz’s superior, was the chairwoman at the time. State Secretary Britta Behrendt (CDU) will take over until the position is filled. Source: rbb

 

NEWS FROM GERMANY

Champagne, Rolexes and racism

At the end of last week, a short video went viral. The video was taken last Sunday in the exclusive club ‘Pony’ in Kampen on the island of Sylt. A group of young people sing the phrase ‘Foreigners out, Germany to the Germans’ to Gigi D’Agostino’s song ‘L’Amour toujours’. The Nazi version was also sung on Monday at the Schützenfest in Löningen in the district of Cloppenburg. In the midst of these scenes, bottles of champagne are opened, using the teeth, or credit cards. All of it makes clear that racist statements are not just a phenomenon of boozing neo-Nazis. Source: taz

CDU cancels online vote against combustion engine ban

The planned ban on combustion engines for new cars has met with disapproval from the CDU, and the party wanted to secure support with an online poll.  However, reports from the Bild am Sonntag claim that things didn’t go according to the CDU’s plan.  The vote took place last saturday and in the morning more than 85 per cent of participants were in favour of a ban. The poll was taken offline in the afternoon and the vote cancelled. This was justified by Christoph Schleifer, who works for the company commissioned to conduct the survey, speaking of massive manipulation. He claims that ‘Tens of thousands of votes were cast automatically.’Source: tagesschau

Palestinian Liberation is Inseparable From the Climate Struggle

Israeli genocide of Palestinians rests heavily on perpetrating an ecocide both locally and globally.

I’ve sat countless times in meetings of environmental groups, while people discussed how to attract a more diverse range of people to become active in advocating for climate policy. Many groups, which tend towards white and middle or upperclass, find that they have trouble connecting with other activists, despite the fact that the existential threat of climate change is intimately involved with nearly every other struggle. I’ve also heard some of the reasons for this disconnect from activists in other areas; the issue of the climate isn’t as urgent as others, or that they don’t feel as welcome in such homogenous spaces. And another, less palatable one: that climate activists are too often single issue, making the lack of intersectionality alienating.

…Israel’s relentless bombardment of Gaza has “produced more planet-warming gases than 20 climate-vulnerable nations do in a year.”

A lot of the overlap between climate topics and other struggles is nuanced. It’s not always easy to connect things like poorer health and life expectancy in underserved communities to the food system, or heat deaths to urban planning that favors some neighborhoods over others. As a giant monolith of a topic, climate change can often seem pretty invisible. But one area where the connection cannot be ignored is war, and specifically Israel’s genocide of Palestinians. Surprisingly (or maybe not?), many climate activists are trying their very hardest to do exactly that.

Every step of conflict generates greenhouse gas emissions. Weapons need to be manufactured, which uses energy and also carbon-intensive materials. They need to be transported from one place to another, which is done via jets burning heavy fuel, or ships, which release not only carbon dioxide but also sulfur into the atmosphere – a cause of acid rain. Then there is the cost of transporting and housing troops, which again includes transport plus electricity, food, and clothing. Bombs and other weapons cause fire, smoke, and create rubble, resulting in a massive carbon explosion. Watching a video of a bomb detonating, you can literally see the black smoke rising into the air to obscure the sun. Even coal power plants don’t look that bad.

According to data shared with The Guardian, Israel’s relentless bombardment of Gaza has “produced more planet-warming gases than 20 climate-vulnerable nations do in a year.” That’s equivalent to 150,000 tonnes of coal and was “probably a significant underestimate.” The article was also written in January, so that figure has no doubt risen significantly in the time since then. And these kinds of figures are just the ones that we know. What we don’t know is how much greenhouse gas comes from militaries around the world because governments refuse to say, citing national security. One researcher has estimated that the U.S. military “contributes more greenhouse gas emissions than over 150 countries.” This report on the carbon footprint of EU militaries had to extrapolate much of the data, and notes that “no EU militaries attempt to report on the GHG emissions related to weapons use on the battlefield.”

And besides the catastrophic loss of human life from this genocide, apartments, schools, and other structures are also being flattened to the ground. These are made mostly of concrete, and are greenhouse gas bombs themselves. They release plant-warming gasses both when they are destroyed and when they’ll need to be rebuilt in the future. To put how much of an impact buildings have on the planet in context, the construction industry is responsible for around one third of global emissions (33%) – more than transportation (24%) and agriculture (21%). The U.N. estimates that rebuilding all the destroyed homes in Gaza could take 80 years. Between the (underestimated) emissions from active war, and the future emissions from rebuilding alone, every climate activist should be doing everything they can for Palestine.

But the deep connection between Palestinian liberation and climate advocacy didn’t start on October 7th – Israel’s occupation of Palestine has always been a climate issue. Back in 2002 the situation had gotten so severe that the UNEP was asked to undertake an in depth study on environmental issues in Palestine. Klaus Töpfer, then Director of the UNEP, wrote in the foreword that “the deepening crisis and the human suffering in the region cannot be neglected and the international community should do its utmost to assist those who are affected. The peaceful end of the occupation and cessation of all violence must be the ultimate objective. Environmental cooperation can be a tool in the peace process.”

A main environmental issue in occupied Palestine that has only worsened over the last months is water contamination, both of the groundwater and the ocean. Israel controls all of the water supply, leaving the Palestinians to pump groundwater, drawing from sensitive aquifers in the area. The overdrawing of groundwater is a concern in itself, but this has historically been compounded by heavy, often illegal use of pesticides and fertilizers in the West Bank, which run into the Palestinian water supply and contaminate it. In such an arid area of the world, this isn’t only bad for people, but also native plants and animals who rely on the scarce water to survive. Adequate waste facilities aren’t supplied to Palestinians, and treatment plants are often overloaded, flowing into the ocean. It’s also been reported that Israeli settlers discharge wastewater onto Palestinian land or into the ocean. With the escalation of Israel’s assault on Gaza, chemicals from weapons and illegal white phosphorus have also made it into water, and Israel has cut off the water supply entirely. The remaining water is so contaminated that many are being forced to drink seawater, or from puddles, and it’s not known when the aquifers will recover.

Another existing issue that has been made exponentially worse over the past months is that of waste. The Palestinian trash collecting system suffers near-constant disruption because of changing Israeli checkpoints, and closing off of various areas to Palestinians and Palestinian vehicles. This has routinely led to dump sites being created outside of managed landfills, which leak methane, a greenhouse gas over 28 times as potent as carbon dioxide. Even worse, because of the lack of infrastructure and disruptions, trash is also burned, which releases toxic chemicals into the air. The recent destruction of buildings in Gaza has created an unimaginable amount of rubble and other waste, and these underlying problems mean there’s nowhere for it to go.

But perhaps the most devastating impact to the environment in Palestine has been to the region’s biodiversity. Water pollution and that from landfills has major effects on plant and animal species, which are under threat in occupied Palestine. Israel also routinely clears large areas for security purposes, destroying native trees and shrubs, and flattening the land. It also limits Palestinians’ access to the ocean, which means that the area near the shore is heavily overfished. And as native people, Palestinians have developed plant species to cultivate for food over generations that are suited to the region. One of those species is olive trees, whose oil has formed a significant part of the Palestinian economy and culture. Some of the trees are centuries older than the Israeli occupation. Because of checkpoints, many farmers have long had troubles tending to their farms, meaning the loss of the trees, along with heritage varieties of fruits and vegetables. Israelis also routinely uproots and destroys the trees, sometimes thousands at a time. This has only increased since October 7th, with the FAO and UN estimating that over one third of agricultural land in Gaza has been destroyed.

There aren’t many cases where the connections between a liberation struggle and the climate are clearer: Palestinian liberation is intimately connected to the environment, not only within Palestine, but also with repercussions extending far beyond it. Those in the climate movement have the chance to deepen the solidarity with other struggles, and to make the push for environmental protection more intersectional. Even though they’ve gotten massive pushback, some like Elisa Bas and Greta Thunberg, have already done so. But more is needed, especially within Germany, where climate activists mostly remain silent. But to care about the environment, and especially to call oneself a climate activist, goes hand in hand with support for Palestine.

The Unpublished Answers

Only in the movies you can beautifully love your offender.


27/05/2024

Let me show you the meaning of ‘running in place.’

I wrote the interview ‘Liberating People, Not Territories’ for Freedom Press in just one evening. In the process, I stopped to dance three times, pleased with how the text was turning out. But the interview ‘These Are Truly Dangerous People’ for the Left Berlin took me 9 days. 9 damn days!

Despite the challenging process of writing the interview, I still consider it a logical continuation of the one for Freedom Press.

What took me the most time was one, seemingly simple, question. It went like this:

If you could return to Ukraine without consequence, would you?

And here are the multiple answers. The point is that these answers are different, but each of them is truthful. That’s why I want to share them with you.

Answer 1: If I can believe that I am more than my nationality. If I persuade my readers that culture knows no boundaries. Then one can conclude that home for me doesn’t end with Ukrainian borders. Moreover, my home doesn’t even begin there.

Answer 2: Last month, when I was watching Ukrainian news, they were discussing the opportunity to put guys in prison up to 8 years who did not return from Europe to go to war. Do I need to comment on this?

Answer 3: The last time I watched Ukrainian news, they discussed the fact that Ukrainian citizens abroad who publicly speak or write something different from the official narrative about Ukraine will be imprisoned for a term of 10 years to life.

Ukraine is a threat to my life. I have no sentimental feelings towards someone who bullies me. Anyway, it doesn’t sound like I could return to Ukraine without consequence. Even my literary imagination is not able to answer the question posed in the interview directly.

I’ve provided abbreviated versions of the answers. In reality, there were many more of them. And it was like this for every question.

That’s why I called it a practice in ‘running on the spot’. If you’ve ever been in a car stuck in the mud, wheels spinning hopelessly, you know the feeling.

It shows that even if your contribution against war seems trivial, it’s still worth making. As you can see, the interview is ready. It’s published. An elegant interview about inelegant matters. Similarly, your victory may be not something astonishing, but it will be an inevitable continuation of the previous step.

Here you can read the interview and find out how exactly I answered that not so simple question – “These are truly dangerous people”.

This piece is a part of  a series, The Mining Boy Notes, published on Mondays and authored by Ilya Kharkow, a writer from Ukraine. For more information about Ilya, see his website. You can support his work by buying him a coffee.

 

Spain and Selling Arms to Israel

We need deeds, not words


25/05/2024

Historically, and especially since October 2023, Spain has been a supporter of the Palestinian cause. Already days after 7 October, both the left-wing press and left-wing political forces made statements putting the Hamas attack in context. These classified it as resistance against the occupying power, and even compare it to the Warsaw ghetto uprising. This was unthinkable to see or read in Germany. In Spain, people on the left, from the most radical to the most centrist, support the Palestinian cause without fissures. In fact, after the arrival of democracy in Spain, following the death of the fascist dictator Francisco Franco in 1975, Spain began diplomatic relations with Palestine in 1977.  Only nine years later, in 1986, did Spain establish diplomatic relations with Israel. This support was across the political spectrum. The left supported Palestine because of the struggle against occupation and apartheid. The right because of its deep antisemitism, and not because it believed in the fundamental rights of the Palestinian people. Even Franco, a rabid antisemite, refused to recognise the state of Israel during his almost 40 years of dictatorship, unlike most European governments at the time.

Today, a large part of the Spanish right is still antisemitic but is being dragged along by the latest trend – the Zionist movement. On the weekend of 17-19 May, a congress of the European far right was held with the participation of famous antisemites including Viktor Orbán. It was attended by Amichai Chikli, Israel’s Minister of Diaspora Affairs, who is supposed to fight antisemitism. Chikli was invited as a symbol of the Spanish ultra-right’s support for Israel in its offensive on the Gaza Strip. For those who claim to defend the Jewish people to meet with fascists and neo-Nazis, only undermines the real fight against growing antisemitism.

The current socialist government of Spain is one of the leaders in the European Union in the defense of the Palestinian people in the ongoing genocide. On 22th May 2024, together with Ireland and Norway, Spain recognised Palestine as a country, a welcome decision. But one that leaves a bitter taste of white phosphorus and rivers of Palestinian blood that had to be spilled for the Palestinian people’s rights to finally be recognised.

But this government is playing both sides of the game. While it trumpeted that it had halted sending arms to Israel after 7 October, reports in various newspapers suggest that this is not entirely true. In fact, not only did it continue to send arms worth almost a million Euros, but the defence ministry’s awards of contracts to Israeli companies or their subsidiaries in Spain have not ceased to this day.

According to the information published in the diario.es, “bombs, grenades, torpedoes, mines, missiles, cartridges and other ammunition and projectiles, and their parts, including shells, pellets and cartridge cases” were exported for use in “weapons of war”.

The article continues: “The Secretary of State for Trade assured this newspaper that the export “corresponds to licences authorised before 7 October” and maintains that it contains “material for tests or demonstrations, in no case for final use or to be used in the conflict”. The next day they contacted the newspaper again to specify that what was sent was “medium calibre non-explosive ammunition”.

The same article argues that the sale had been authorised prior to 7 October is not a reason to proceed with it. Since the regulation on the control of the arms trade in defence, states these authorisations can be cancelled if there are “reasonable indications” that the material is going to be used in actions “that disturb the peace”. Such is the case of a possible genocide, announced by the Zionist leaders from day one.

And the fact is that Spain, like most of the West, enjoys a fruitful arms trade relationship with Israel. We sell our weapons, Spain is the 7th largest arms exporter in the world. In return we buy from Israel weapons and technology “proven in combat”, namely on Palestinian bodies, paying money with which Israel finances the occupation and apartheid.

As the newspaper El Salto points out, “In a contract signed in November alone (2023), Spain bought Israeli Spike LR2 missiles for 287.5 million euros. According to the Centre Delás Negocios report, in addition to the army, the clients of the Israeli military and security industry include the Ministry of Defence, the CNI, the National Police Corps, the Guardia Civil and the various regional police forces”.

In the Borkum scandal, a German cargo ship rang alarm bells because of leaks that it carried arms from India to Israel. It passed through European ports, including Spain. That highlighted the current government’s apathy in moving from words to deeds. The government was not inclined to inspect the cargo ship once it was in port, not even to silence the alarm bells.

The Spanish government twittered insults on the intelligence and integrity of anyone concerned about the allegations. That included the UN Special Rapporteur on the situation of Palestine Albanese, the European Legal Support Center (ELSC) team of lawyers, the three parties to the left of the PSOE, Podemos, Sumar and Anticapitalistas, as well as the BDS Spain movement. The tweets branded anyone calling for the inspection of the ship as conspiratorial and transmitting fake news.

In the end, after tense hours and a lot of mud, the Borkum did not stop in Cartagena, but it did stop in the Canary Islands. There the government assured that the papers were in order, despite the fact that according to leaked information the papers were stamped on 31 May 2023 and the cargo codes did not coincide with what the ship had declared. By pure coincidence, the government assured us during those hours that it would not allow the Danish ship Marianne Danica, which was carrying 26.8 tonnes of military equipment bound for Haifa (Israel), to stop over. Since last week, numerous ships have been spotted making similar routes that curiously avoid passing close to Yemen, as Luis Arbide of the Delás centre shows.

It would be useful to have explanations from the Spanish government as to what material passes through our NATO air and sea bases, knowing that the US is Israel’s main arms supplier. For example, we now know that the US ship transporting weapons straight to Gaza, vía the infamous pier “built for aid”, stopped at the military port base of Rota, in southern Spain.

What this incident shows is first that Spain and Spanish companies continue to do business almost as usual with the genocidal state. Secondly that it turns a blind eye to the ships that avoid the route where they can be intercepted by the Huthi. This is not legally or morally correct. That would require at least to inspect them and seize the contents if they are materials to be used in the massacres that we watch helplessly on our screens every day.

How should Socialists React to Britain’s coming Election?

Sunak must go, but Starmer will be little better


24/05/2024

The sight of a sodden Rishi Sunak dripping wet in the pouring rain telling us to vote for his Conservative Party because it had a plan for the future sums up the current situation of the Tory Party. Sunak, rain running down his Armani suit, called the election and asked us to vote for him on the basis that he was going to fix things. Seemingly forgetting that it is his party that has been in power for 14 years.

Britain is still staggering from the  financial crisis of 2008. On average a worker is now £14,000 worse off per year due to that crisis in the worst period for wage growth since the Napoleonic Wars.

As evidenced on Wednesday the Tories are washed up. They have for several years now been unable to put forward a coherent plan for British capitalism, instead lurching from one right wing culture war policy to another.

The horrific Rwanda deportation plan was never a practical policy even in right wing terms, it was instead a signal to the right wing voter that the Tories hated foreigners as much as they do. The horror of the Johnson premiership and the comic opera term of Liz Truss followed by the nothingness of Sunak clearly demonstrated that the Tory Party is running on empty.

An election is to be welcomed, in fact it has been long called for, but what attitude should the Left take?

It is almost a certainty that the Labour Party will win the election with a large majority. Unfortunately this will be under the leadership of Kier Starmer, a man who has bent over backwards to have no policy that might offend any boss anywhere. This spineless attitude was compounded when Starmer slavishly followed the line of the imperialist states in backing Israel’s right to commit genocide in Gaza. Asked by radio host Nick Ferrari whether cutting off power and water was “appropriate”, Starmer said: “I think that Israel does have that right. It is an ongoing situation.”

This was massively unpopular with Labour voters, with many tearing up their membership cards and a swathe of councillors resigning the Labour whip and sitting as independents. Labour has since tried to row back from that line to a position of simply equivocation but continues to back the Israeli state.

Nevertheless, for the majority of voters, the priority will simply be to get rid of the Tories. Socialists should definitely be in this camp! Millions and millions of workers will be there.

However to simply cheer Labour on is impossible. The Labour Party under Starmer has adopted policies that are little different from the Tories: they only say that they will carry out the cuts more slowly and with a smile instead of a snarl. They will continue the racist immigration policies of the right and they nothing to relieve workers from the oppressive anti union laws enacted in the last few years.

Labour no longer even defends the integrity of the National Health Service. Shadow Health Secretary Wes Streeting has said that the NHS needs to use the “capacity” of private health care providers, and will shovel millions of pounds into their coffers. Labour is also fast back tracking on its green policies. Keir Starmer has already announced that he is scaling back Labour’s £28bn annually green investment programme.

Fortunately a space has opened up to the left of Labour. The massive pro Palestine movement in the UK and worldwide has provided the space for serious challenges to Labour. “No ceasefire, no vote”, has become a popular slogan. There was already a fallout from Labour as Starmer and his cohorts used the charge of antisemitism to witch-hunt Jeremy Corbyn and the left out of the party. The collapse of the potency of that slander as it is used to justify the genocide in Gaza has opened the eyes of many more. Starmer’s positions on Gaza have led to widespread disillusionment with Labour especially in strongly Muslim areas but not confined to them.

This challenge will be led by former Labour leader Jeremy Corbin who has announced he is to stand as an independent in his constituency of Islington North. Every socialist will be supporting him. Unfortunately, however, Corbyn left it to the last minute to announce his candidacy although it was long expected. This delay means that there is no time to build his challenge as a national one. If he had gone earlier a network could have been created with a national presence.

Nevertheless a Corbyn victory will be a slap in the face of Starmer. Corbyn has been a dedicated and very hard working MP in his constituency for decades. In fact one of the most common sights in Islington is to see Jeremy cycling past on the way to visit some constituent or other. It is probable that he will win.

Starter himself will be challenged by the left wing activist Andrew Feinstein in Holborn and St Pancras. The former anti apartheid activist will fight a good campaign. A whole host of other candidates will stand as a left alternative from Luton to Liverpool and they should be supported.

George Galloway’s Workers Party of Britain will also stand in a large number of places. I don’t think this is an appropriate vote for leftists. Whilst Galloway is very good on Palestine, he has adopted a whole range of homophobic, transphobic and anti women stances. He has also adapted to the right over immigration in a manner similar to Sahra Wagenknecht in Germany. We can’t throw the oppressed under the bus because Galloway says the right things about Gaza.

Important as the election is, it is not the most important thing happening in British politics. This remains the necessity to continue building the massive movement in support of Palestine. It is this movement, here and worldwide, that is opening up the cracks in the international imperialist order. The ICC decision to pursue arrest warrants for Netanyahu and co is one example of this. The imperialist arguments around Israel are no longer common sense.

The decision to carry on marching, with the 15th National Demonstration for Palestine being called for June 8th in London is welcome. It is the movement for Palestine that has opened up the challenge to the left of Labour and it is important that the movement remains on the streets and is not sidetracked into simply electioneering. The movement can bring about a wholesale change in politics not simply focusing on who forms the next government. The student encampment indicates the possibilities here.

So, in my opinion, get the Tories out, vote as left as you can but carry on building the movement for Palestine!